?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Questions concerning HP/TW fic

Okay so I am working on "The magic bonds" my story where Ianto is the son of Sirius and Remus I need some help so I turn to you my readers.

What house at Hogwarts should Ianto have been in? This is very important because it plays into Ianto past relationships. Also who would you like to see have a crush on Ianto, Draco? Harry? Or both?

I am going to be away from the internet this weekend and want to work on some of my stories and this is one of them, so any ideas would help.

Thanks so much.

Comments

( 8 comments — Leave a comment )
aige09
Jan. 25th, 2011 03:17 am (UTC)
Delurking for this, because Ianto as the son of Remus and Sirius, exciting.

Of course the problem is, is that I can see Ianto in all of the Houses, Remus and Sirius would want him to be a Gryffindor, but equally he could be a Ravenclaw (Clever, sarcastic), Slytherin (Sneaky) or a Hufflepuff (Loyal (Lisa)). I do think he'd make a fantastic Ravenclaw though, breaking the mould with his sarcasm, and his general personality. Be someone who stood out in that House, after all as Sirius' son, he's bound to stand out.

As to Draco and Harry, well Draco's actually not all that nice as a person, and I like to think Ianto has better taste in people than that so I'd have to vote for Harry. Although I can see some problems in that relationship too, since Harry likes to throw himself into danger, much like Jack. So in that case, Draco might be a better choice because he's different to both Jack and Harry. I'll read whichever one you choose. But my vote's still for Harry.

Whew, long comment, sorry. I'll stop annoying you now.
backrose_17
Jan. 25th, 2011 05:32 am (UTC)
I love the idea of Ianto being Sirius and Remus son.

*Hits head against desk.* That is my problem too, Ianto fits in all the Houses. I do like the idea of Ianto being in Ravenclaw, he wold fits so well after all. I have read stories where Ianto has been in Gryffindor and Slytherin it would be nice to do something different. And as Sirius son there is no doubt that Ianto would stand anywhere.

I am thinking of having both Draco and Harry having a crush on Ianto, because really who wouldn't?

I don't mind long comments, the longer the better. Thank you for you input.
irishjantogirl
Jan. 25th, 2011 04:19 pm (UTC)
Well he's smart to be a Ravenclaw but then you have to remember Hermione was the smartest witch of all the HP universe and was in Gryffindor. Gryffindor suits him the best.
It's their daring, nerve and chivalry that set gryffindors apart after all.
daring and nerve= all the stuff with lisa, the cannibals and the really kickass bit in meat with the stun gun.... as for chivalry: it's Ianto we're on about. our of all the TW guys he was probably the most chivalrous. the knight in a perfect suit if yoou will...

as for a crush, i think Harry would feel more rotherly towards him if he was Siruis and Lupin's kid and he'd be a half/blood and not a Slytherin which would make him sort of forbidden fruit in Draco's case and make him somewhat more appelaing.

go with Draco having the crush :)
backrose_17
Jan. 29th, 2011 05:01 am (UTC)
I agree with all your reasons and really am torn between Gryffindor and Ravenclaw for Ianto, they are the house that seem to fit Ianto best.

I'm going with Harry starting out with a crush on Ianto that turns into brotherly love. Draco is going to be the one with a crush on Ianto. I can't help but love the idea of Draco/Ianto.
amuse_g
Jan. 26th, 2011 01:02 am (UTC)
Ianto as a...Hufflepuff

Right, I can see Ianto as any house however with both his parents as Gryffs I think he would want to be a Gryf, I think the Sorting Hat would actually tell him his options and why he would fit in all the Houses. I lean towrds Hufflepuff because Ianto has an incredical level of loyalty which I think overrides all else. He was sneaky to protect Lisa and later to protect people from finding out about aliens, which as a magical he might believe they are not ready to know (what's that saying about one person is smart but many people would panic). So I would think leaset likely would be Slytherin. Ravenclaw as he is intelligent and loves to know everything but not to the exclusion of all else as I believe. Plus as Remus is book loving and smart Ianto might be happy with that House...although is Remus a book fanatic because he wanted to be or because as he was bitten so young books became his friends? A Gryff would work but I believe most of what Ianto did, all his brave acts, trying to save Lisa, becoming a field agent when Jack left, helping teammates (being Gwen's wedding fairy) was due to his loyalty.

I think that Ianto, like Harry, would have a House preference which he would try and convince the hat to put him in but I don't think Ianto would have any House prejudices.

I hope this helped I know I rambled a bit.

amuse_g
backrose_17
Jan. 29th, 2011 05:03 am (UTC)
Re: Ianto as a...Hufflepuff
I was planning on the hat giving Ianto his options, actually I have that part written and that is were I got stuck because I couldn't figure out what house is best for Ianto. I'm most likely going to have the sorting hat leave it up to Ianto to pick which house he wants, hopefully my Ianto muse will have made a choice by then.
jayamionedurron
Jan. 29th, 2011 06:32 am (UTC)
OOO that is hard. If the hat gives him a choice i'd def say no to slytherin cause he'd know what type of people he'd end up having to be friends with. I think it would be a toss up between griff and raven. i can't see him as a hufflepuff, he has way to many of the other characteristics for loyality to be his dominating factor. esp with sirius and remus as parents.

i don't think i can make up my mind though. on one had griff makes sense and is given a choice he have lots of reasons to choose it. on the other hand i think he's independant enough to choose ravenclaw if he thinks that it will help him grow more.

i think it comes down to which bits of his personality ou're going to empahsise.

i REALLY want the intro to the SOON though :D
backrose_17
Jan. 31st, 2011 06:56 pm (UTC)
I think I might have figured out which house Ianto is going to be in, I took in all the views of my readers and put Ianto in the house that best fits him.

I will be putting up a little teasing post this week to give you a taste of the story.
( 8 comments — Leave a comment )

Profile

Supernatural - Never Let Go
backrose_17
backrose_17

Latest Month

February 2018
S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728   

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com